Abū Mansūr al-Baghdādī in Manāqib al-Shafi’ī and Naqd Abī `Abd Allah al-Jurjānī fī Tarjīh Madh’hab Abī Hanīfa relates the following example of the Imām’s perspicuity at an early age:
Al-Shāfi’ī was sitting at Mālik’s feet one day when a man came in and said: “I sell turtle-doves, and one of my customers returned one of them to me today, saying that it does not coo, so I swore to him on pain of divorce that my turtle-dove coos all the time!” Malik said: “You have divorced your wife and are not to approach her.” Al-Shāfi’ī was fourteen at the time. He said to the man: “Which is more, your turtle-dove’s cooing or its silence?” The man said: “Its cooing.”
Al-Shāfi’ī said: “Consider your marriage valid, and there is no penalty on you.”
Whereupon Mālik frowned at him saying: “Boy! How do you know this?” Al-Shāfi’ī replied: “Because you narrated to me from al-Zuhrī, from Abu Salama ibn `Abd al-Rahmān, from Umm Salama, that Fatima bint Qays said: ‘O Messenger of Allah! Abu Jahm and Mu`awiya have both proposed to me.’
The Prophet may Allah Almighty bless him and grant him peace, replied: ‘As for Mu`awiya he is penniless, and as for Abu Jahm he does not put down his staff from his shoulder [from travel].’
Meaning: in most of his states; for the Arabs declare the more frequent of two actions [exclusively of the other] because of its constancy. And since the cooing of this man’s turtledove is more than its silence, I declared it constant in its cooing.” Malik was pleased at his reasoning.
1 Narrated by Bukhārī and Muslim.
2 In Ibn al-Subkī, Tabaqāt al-Shāfi’īyya al-Kubra (5:147-148).